Tired Eyes? This Surprising Eyeliner Shade Might Just Be Your Secret Weapon
We’ve all heard the age-old beauty tip: brown eyeliner is the go-to for softening features and taking years off your appearance. But here’s where it gets controversial—what if there’s an even better option? During a recent chat with renowned Spanish makeup artist Natalia Belda (https://www.instagram.com/natalia_natalita/?hl=en), I discovered a game-changing twist on this classic rule. While brown certainly has its merits, Belda introduced me to a more nuanced approach that’s been making waves on 2026 runways and beauty counters alike: reddish tones. And this is the part most people miss—it’s not just about any red; it’s about finding the right red to neutralize dark circles and give your eyes a well-rested glow, no matter your age.
Before you rush to grab the brightest red liner you can find, Belda emphasizes the importance of nuance. The key lies in selecting a shade that complements your skin type, undertone (https://www.vogue.com/article/color-analysis-makeup), eye color, and the specific nature of your dark circles. ‘As a general rule,’ she explains, ‘reddish pigments tend to be incredibly flattering and softer on the eyes compared to black or brown, which can sometimes harden features—especially as we age.’ While these shades won’t magically turn back time, they do something just as powerful: they refresh the eyes, neutralize under-eye darkness, and soften that tired look—but only if you choose wisely.
Choosing the Right Shade: It’s Not All Red and Games
Not all reds are created equal when it comes to disguising dark circles (https://www.vogue.com/article/how-to-treat-dark-circles). Belda warns that bright or true reds can actually backfire, exaggerating signs of fatigue or eye redness and making pink-toned dark circles more noticeable. Instead, she recommends opting for subdued, brown-tinged variations—think burgundy rather than tomato red. ‘These well-selected shades can bring more light to the eye area and enhance your natural eye color,’ she says. It’s all about balance.
Belda also shared a universal tip that’s too good not to pass on: ‘Regardless of your liner shade, start by neutralizing the eyelid with a small amount of concealer (https://www.vogue.com/article/how-to-apply-concealer-pro-expert-guide-dark-circles-bags-blemishes) applied with a brush. Then, gently blend it out using soft taps of your fingers for a seamless finish.’
From Eyes to Cheeks: The Red Revolution Continues
Our conversation naturally flowed into the latest trend in blushes—red and burgundy shades (https://www.vogue.com/slideshow/best-blush) that are flooding the market. Belda notes that their success hinges on intensity, but when done right, they can be universally flattering, giving most complexions a healthy, modern glow. ‘They’re a refreshing alternative to classic pink tones,’ she adds.
Products to Try:
- Chanel: Stylo Yeux Waterproof Eyeliner in Eros
- Lancôme: Le Stylo Long-Lasting Eyeliner in Ruby Fever
- L'Oréal Paris: Haute Couleur Kohl Eyeliner Pencil in Burgundy Cashmere
- Victoria Beckham Beauty: Satin Kajal Liner in Bordeaux
Now, Here’s the Controversial Question: Could reddish eyeliner truly replace brown as the go-to shade for brightening tired eyes? Or is this just a passing trend? Let us know your thoughts in the comments—we’d love to hear your take! And if you’ve got a beauty or wellness trend you’re curious about, drop Vogue’s senior beauty & wellness editor an email at beauty@vogue.com. Let’s keep the conversation going!
